Sheeley House Saloon

Visited here on a recommendation from a good friend. Atmosphere was very nice, the wait staff was on point. Friday fish fry this is a different story. They have a Mahi Mahi special on Fridays. Mahi is a very delectable fish and should never be treated with the disrespect that they put this filet through. The batter they used was despicable and had to be removed in order to eat it. Literally 1/2 thick. Truffle fries...under recommendation also felt as if they had been reheated, and all I tasted was a lot of garlic and parmesan. At nearly $50 for a fish fry for my wife and I we both agreed that the only thing that was refreshing was the coleslaw.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

We hadn't been there in a long time. It was a very pleasant experience. Service was outstanding, with the server being friendly and welcoming and kept checking on us. Food was only so-so. Burgers were not made to order, they were overdone. Regular fries had no flavor. Bun wasn't toasted. Pickle juice saturated the bun. The shrimp appetizer was amazing. The truffle fries are great.Atmosphere was very nice and we were able to talk without shouting. Music was subdued. Even though it fairly busy, it was quiet and comfortable.We will stop again and try something else next time.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Really good food. The desert cluck sandwich and truffle fries were excellent. Fun ambience with great history and a perfect vibe for the Halloween season!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Great local pub Friendly and efficient staff. Great pub food. Welcoming and comfortable. Good drinks selection. Nice atmosphere.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Super Super Super nice staff. The food was amazing and the whole restaurant gave a vintage rustic atmosphere.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply