You will maybe be redirected
"I am a little biased because thus has become my neighborhood hang out place. We have pizza here almost every Friday night. Love the food, drinks (the Not That Old Fashioned is my favorite) and the staff. We like the number 11 and suggest you try the number 14 with smoked chicken and hot honey."
Phone: +16123422625
Address: North Washington Avenue, 600, Neapolis Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews, United States Of America, neapolis Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews
City: neapolis Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews
Website: https://blacksheeppizza.com/
Monday: 11:00-22:00
Tuesday: 11:00-22:00
Wednesday: 11:00-22:00
Thursday: 11:00-22:00
Friday: 11:00-00:00
Saturday: 11:00-00:00
Sunday: 11:00-22:00
Dishes: 36
Amenities: 13
Categories: 5
Reviews: 3726
It was okay. I’d come back if my friends wanted to but probably wouldn’t pick it myself. I wouldn’t order the same things either. I’d like to think I’m not fussy. I like standard basic foods and it’s disappointing when restaurants don’t deliver. The pepperoni pizza was just “alright.” The crust is super thin and on its own tastes like a cracker, very bland and dry. The sauce had a good tomato flavor but that’s it, a little bit on the sweeter side. There was barely any cheese on the pizza and it was unevenly distributed so some slices had good coverage and others were almost bare. The pepperoni was pretty good, no real complaints other than being maybe excessively greasy. The peach cobbler was not good. The flavor was okay, nothing special except the slivered almonds they sprinkle on top. The cobbler part was slimy- it is a cake based cobbler not a biscuit based cobbler. The crust was a little burnt on the side. The service was ~okay~. I came by myself, around 640pm on a Monday. I think I was the only 1-person table there, so I get why I wouldn’t be a server’s first priority. (I’ve been a server myself so I really do understand). However, only one check up and that was immediately after the food was delivered. Nothing after that until they suggested they would bring the check. Where’s the up-sell? I probably would have ordered another drink and flagged down another server when I decided to get the cobbler. No refills on my water. It took almost 20 minutes for the 12-inch pepperoni pizza to be delivered to my table and about 15 minutes for the cobbler. This place seems popular for groups. You order multiple small pizzas, they’re delivered on tiered stands, and you share. However, it’s *incredibly* loud. With the industrial vibe (bare concrete and exposed beams and pipes), there is absolutely nothing dampening sound. There’s an open kitchen and open door into the dish washing room. All of this combined to a very unpleasant sound environment. It was fairly expensive for what it is. $35. I got one of the cheapest drinks, cider, and the cocktails are at least double the price. If you’re coming here and having more than one drink, sharing multiple pizzas, maybe ordering dessert, expect to shell out. I had no trouble finishing it all on my own. Granted, I missed lunch so was very hungry. For comparison, I usually struggle to finish a burrito bowl, so this food isn’t very substantial.
They reached out and made thing right, corrected to 5 stars. Old review below, have since gone back and had a amazing time. Take out is online ordering only and it said to pick it up at 12:15. We got there at 12:02 to make sure we got the pizza when to was fresh but it was already sitting on the counter and was barely only luke warm. Which in the 3 minutes it took us to drive to the nearby park it was room temperature. Room temperature pizza that’s been steaming in the box for a half hour is disappointing. Also they have 4% wellness charge. Just raise the price of your pizza 4%. Charge what it cost to run your business.
Came in here. Warmly greeted and after I looked at the menu I asked this kind woman about her favorites: #5, #1, and #4 in that ordered. I also had the lemon/thyme chicken skewer and some kind of lamb skewer. The skewers came first and it packed a ton of flavor I was happy with the suggestion to mix and match! I ordered the #4 pizza she described it as having a lasagna feel and I can confirm that's the case. I will try the #5 pizza since she said that has been her favorite for over 20 years?! Crazy. Fantastic experience
Absolutely loved our experience at Black Sheep Coal Fired Pizza! The pizza was incredible – perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and delightful flavors that kept us wanting more. Our server, Emily, made the experience even better with her friendly and welcoming attitude. She was knowledgeable about the menu and helped us choose the perfect pizza. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a fantastic meal and top-notch service!
I am a little biased because thus has become my neighborhood hang out place. We have pizza here almost every Friday night. Love the food, drinks (the Not That Old Fashioned is my favorite) and the staff. We like the number 11 and suggest you try the number 14 with smoked chicken and hot honey.
