Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

6401 Jericho Turnpike, 11725, Commack, United States
3212 Reviews 4.5

"Limited menu, but wonderful pizza and salads!"

Details

Phone: +16318582625

Address: 6401 Jericho Turnpike, 11725, Commack, United States

City: Commack

Website: https://acfp.com/location/commack/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30 -22:00

Tuesday: 11:30 -22:00

Wednesday: 11:30 -22:00

Thursday: 11:30 -22:00

Friday: 11:30 -23:00

Saturday: 11:30 -23:00

Sunday: 11:30 -22:00

Statistics

Dishes: 54

Amenities: 14

Categories: 5

Reviews: 3212


Address

Show Map

Reviews

5 /5 Rating

Really good pizza and an incredible reward program! We had the roasted cauliflower (picked) and the traditional (based on their regular cheese). Both were delicious. The cheesecake was really good; our children loved it. Totally worth it. The cauliflower was tasty, but would probably order something else next time. We have registered for their reward program after our server has recommended it and are really happy about the bonuses they offer! A free 12” for registration, a birthday pizza... Good stuff safe. We sat at the outside seats in front of the restaurant. Really not bad considering that the restaurant on JTPKE.

2 /5 Rating

The food has always been good but the way they resolved a mistake with an online order left a lot to be desired. I used their website to place a takeout order. When I got home I realized 1 of the 4 items ordered was missing. It took 10 mins on the phone to get them to refund my credit card (they initially offered a credit towards a future online order). The manager never got on the phone and the amount refunded didn't include the tax I paid on the missing item. Poor service all around.

4 /5 Rating

Stopped here to try the pizza. We also grabbed wings . The pizza is served nicely with a hearty portion for 3 if you split it. The wings are large and juicy , I recommend you ask for well done for a toastier wing. Tried the Carnivori thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon Fuhgeddaboudit. The place is spacious and great for groups, Stop by , grab a fire coal pizza and a cold Peroni you will be pleasantly surprised!

1 /5 Rating

Officially my last time here. $100 for wings and pizza. 30 mins past time to pick up a take out order. Not even an apology. Just standing in a tiny wait area with a few others who are as upset as I am. Done.

5 /5 Rating

Limited menu, but wonderful pizza and salads!